The enigma called the apostrophe........
Generally students attribute the usage of the apostrophe sign to indicate possession. But a closer look at the placement of the apostrophe reveals something else.
Carefully look at what the apostrophe connotes in the following examples:
• It’s means it is; here the apostrophe stands for a missing i
• I’m means I am ; here the apostrophe stands for a missing a
• Ma’am means madam; here the apostrophe stands for a missing d
• 2o’clock means 2 of the clock ; here the apostrophe stands for a missing f
In all these cases an apostrophe simply means a word or a letter missing [traditionally an apostrophe was always used to indicate a letter missing]. So possibly in the usage Sneha’s bag the apostrophe could mean a missing word. Since this phrase means the bag belongs to Sneha it could mean a missing her. How?
This can be traced to a different word order that was a characteristic of old English. Sneha’s bag was written as Sneha her bag/John’s bag was written as John his bag.So an apostrophe with Sneha or John was used to indicate a missing his/her.
Since his and her indicate possession the apostrophe with a noun getst its current meaning that of indicating possession.
On this basis all the rules regarding the usage of the apostrophe can be explained. Here are few of them:
• Inanimate objects do not take an apostrophe (possessive pronouns can be used only for animate objects because only animate objects can possess)
• Possessive pronouns like hers, yours do not take an apostrophe (would lead to duplication)
• Words ending in the sound ‘s’ are followed only by the sign [‘] ( to prevent the hissing sound during pronunciation) e.g. Keats’, Charles’
So logic still prevails
Answers
- Prince Charles' / Charles's friend,Camilla ,is well known in social circles. [though traditional English grammar would not accept the second form , modern English usage does accept]
- The first part of the novel is full of dense prose and delicately nuanced details. [inanimate objects do not take an apostrophe]
- It's time we woke up and remember that each of us is important. [it's = it is / its : possessive pronoun]
- The management is looking for someone with a good knowledge of French and with ten years'/years of experience in teaching. [the plural of year does not take an apostrophe]
- Raju's and Ravi's workshops that are just round the corner,service motorbikes of all kinds. [ since the workshops belong to both Raju and Ravi both the nouns would take an apostrophe]
ma'am,in the last question,why shouldnt the ans be raju and ravi's?
ReplyDeletehi mam can you ellaborate on 1st sentence more..
ReplyDeletehi mam why cant be the answer raju and ravi's in the last question
ReplyDeleteyes i wanna know y it cant be raju and ravi's
ReplyDeleteDear Anonymous (hey guys plz write your names while posting a comment,it helps in answering your queries),
ReplyDeleteRaju and Ravi's workshop can be used when we talk of one workshop belonging to both Raju and Ravi.
But in the last sentence since there are two worshops it has to be Raju's and Ravi's workshops.
Dear Swati,
ReplyDeleteWhen an apostrophe has to be used with a noun ending in 's' to avoid the hissing sound the 's' is dropped and only the apostrophe sign is used.
But according to modern English grammar both the forms are correct.
In question 4, answer is years'/years of. So is it right thst the apostrophe replaces "of" in years'
ReplyDeleteNilisha
sir why wil it be first part of novel???
ReplyDelete