Since a pronoun is a word used in place of a noun the usage of a pronoun depends on three aspects of the noun.These three aspects are as follows:
- number ( SN takes SPr ; PN takes PPr) e.g Ram will be replaced by a he/him/his but Ram and Shyam will be replaced by we/us/our/they/them/their
- gender (Ram [M] takes a he , Sita [F] takes a she , bench [N] takes a it and students [ common] takes a he/she)
- case : the case of a pronoun depends on the position of the noun in a sentence i.e whether a noun is used as a subject,object or used to indicate possession
first person singular : I
second person singular : you
third person singular : he/she/it
first person plural : we
third person plural : they
All these pronouns have four forms depending on their position in the sentence.The following table will help you understand the concept better:
Subjective case Objective case Possessive Adjective Possessive Pr
[used in the subject [used in the object [used to indicate possession]position] position]
I me my mine
you you your yours
he him his his
she her her hers
it it its its
we us our ours
they them their theirs
who whom whose whose
Hence it can be said that the noun and the pronouns should agree with each other in terms of number,case and gender.This error is referred to as Pronoun-Antecedent agreement.
Answers
1) Raghav likes Priya more than me or I (like her is implied with the usage of I) [ either can be used with a change in meaning]
2) Rahul and I would be attending the party tonight. [ When two or more personal pronouns with different persons are used in the same sentence they follow an order.This order depends on the positive or negative meaning conveyed by the sentence.If the sentence conveys a positive meaning the order is : II,III,I and when it conveys a negative meaning the order is : I,II,III]
3) She is taller than I am.[ since we are comparing two subjects here both the pronouns would remain in the subjective case]
4) The hen lay on her eggs. [ hen is a feminine gender and hence her,it is used for an animate beings when the sex is unspecified]
5) Ram and Shyam are good friends. Ram or Shyam stays in the hostel. [In this sentence we cannot use a pronoun as it would lead to ambiguity.]
If you have any queries do post it in the 'comments' section of this blog.
Ma'am, in the 3rd statement, as there is no 'am' at the end of the sentence and the options too do not have an 'am'...would it be right to use 'me'?
ReplyDeletema'am i didnt understand the 5th one !!!!
ReplyDeleteeven i have the same question
ReplyDeleteYes i do agree with priyanka's statement that the third sentence does not have any option as "I am"
ReplyDeleteDeepak/Priya/Ganesh,
ReplyDeleteThe 'am' is implied in the third one as is the 'like her' implied in the first one.You cannot mark the option 'me' as an answer since it would be using the objective case of a pronoun where a subjective case is required.
I hope this solves the conundrum.
Hello Anonymous (please leave your name the next time you post a comment),
ReplyDeleteIn the 5th sentence since there are two nouns (both in the masculine gender) using a pronoun would lead to an ambiguity.Hence we need to specify the noun or use adjectives like former/latter.
If the 5th sentence would have been : Ram and Sita ......then using a he would have been fine to communicate Ram's staying in the hostel.
Ma'am in the last sentence just because the verb "stays" is plural the answer is Ram or Shyam, right? If the verb was just "stay" then the correct answer was "they". Isnt it?
ReplyDeletema'am can u give the example of negative statement which follows the order l,ll,lll as u have mentioned in 2nd
ReplyDeletemam in last sentence they vl come naa
ReplyDeletemam in 5th sentence they should come naa
ReplyDeleteAccept with what Priyanka said in hers first comment.... And Ma'am, there was no punctuation in the last sentence, so did't get that one....
ReplyDeleteHello Ma'am,
ReplyDeleteCan you please explain Question 2?
-Rahul and I would be attending the party tonight.
Dear Sagar,
ReplyDeleteYes.Since the verb 'stays' is singular it would be preceded by a singular noun.If it was 'stay' it would have been 'they' . This noun - verb number agreement is known as subject-verb agreement.
Dear Ankita,
ReplyDeletee.g. of a negative sentence:
I,you and Nidhi should take the blame for the failure of the project.
Dear Chetan,
ReplyDeleteSince the verb 'stays' is singular the subject preceding it should also be singular according the subject verb concord theory.
Since using a 'he' would lead to an ambiguity in meaning we use a noun in place of a pronoun.
Dear Rak [is that your name or a cognomen],
ReplyDeleteSince the blank was also in the dotted format the full stop ending the sentence was not distinctly visible.
Dear Namrata,
ReplyDeleteIf you read the explanation carefully the order of the pronouns depends on the negative or positive meaning conveyed by the sentence.Since the 2nd sentence conveys a positive meaning the third person would precede the first person and hence the answer 'Rahul and I'
ma'm i didnt understand the 3rd one..
ReplyDeleteReferring to the explanation of the 3rd statement, is that a rule we ALWAYS use "subjective" case when comparing two subjects ?
ReplyDeleteSo, can we also use the other subjective pronoun in the sentence ? like....
She is taller than (he is). is it appropriate to use this as well ?
Solved :)
ReplyDeleteThank you Ma'am for this useful post on personal pronouns:)
mam can you explain the 1st statment. wont the answer be only "I" as "I" is not the subject of the sentence, so it should take objective case.?
ReplyDeleteDear Suhas,
ReplyDeleteThe usage of both 'I' and 'me' is correct in the above context.The meaning would change with the change in the usage of the pronoun.If we write : 'Raghav like Priya more than I' (like her) is impliend means both I and Raghav like Priya (here I is a masculine gender).If we write :'Raghav likes Priya more than me' means Raghav likes both Priya and me [here me is a feminine gender]...obviously assuming there are no homosexuality issues :)
Ma'am, in the 3rd statement, as there is no 'am' at the end of the sentence and the options too do not have an 'am'...would it be right to use me
ReplyDeleteMa'am didn't understood 3rd n 5th one
ReplyDelete